Quantcast

Discussion Topic: What kind of expectations do you have for ‘Eclipse’?

Discussion TOpics2

Here is this week’s discussion topic! If you have an idea for a topic, email it to [email protected]!

This week’s topic is from Louise, and she wants to know: What are your expectations of Eclipse? Will it be good? Will it disappoint? Will it be the best/worst of the series so far? My SPOILERy thoughts after the break. Sound off in the comments!

Eclipse is my favorite book of the series. I think the progression of the plot with the Seattle murders and the love triangle are well-written and played out. The cast has repeatedly said how dark this film is going to be because of David Slade’s direction. Then we got stills and a trailer that featured romance romance romance! About that time, we also found out that the editor got replaced. Am I nervous? Alittle. Do I want it to be amazing? YES! But I am keeping my expectations low, so if it isn’t quite what I was hoping for, I won’t be disappointed. And if it is amazing, I will be that much more excited.

Most important scenes for me: tent scene, proposal scene, battle with Victoria and newborns.

  • lucy

    i finsh the book yestrday and i love eclipes so i think it we be the best one so far

  • ZoZo1

    its going to kick ass !!! nd it is my favoret book of the series too!!!!!

  • MandaFromTampa

    I have high hopes for this movie, just as I do for BD. I'm very excited to see the backstories and the engagement. I can't wait to see them graduate and then when she tells Edward “that she wants to stay human for a little while longer.”

  • Treena

    It sounds much the same as the rest of the comments that have been written above but this next movie will be the best yet. We have seen already the building of the saga in Twilight and New Moon but i feel that Eclipse will have the edge that the previous two didn't. The scenes that i am personally looking forward to seeing are not necessarily the ones that have the height of the other fans ideal's. Everyone is looking forward to the fight scene which inits own way is and will be wicked but what about the other parts that are not so much in your face in the book. What about the significant part of Bella breaking her hand when she fights against her feelings for her best friend. What about the part where Jacob, Edward and Bella have an uncomfortable conversation outside the school and the conversaton Rosalie and Bella have in Edwards room. These are significant scenes that should not be forgotton just because there is a more aggressive and volitile scene that is just as significant to the plot aswell. The only thing that i have left to say is roll on june 30th. TEAM EDWARD

  • Ashlea S.

    Well I would have to say I am quite excited about this movie, and I am trying to keep my expectations low. From the book, I the movie contains:
    1. The Love Triangle
    2. Jacob and Edward passing Bella back and forth (like parents passing a child over for custodial time)
    3. Rosalie's Story and Jasper's Story (showing the flashbacks and Jasper's scars)
    4. Bella throwing a tantrum cuz of the bed
    5. Bed scene when Bella lets her emotions run wild
    6. The Proposal and the ring
    7. Charlie and his rude comments towards Edward
    8. Bella breaking her hand from punching Jacob
    9. Alice holding Bella hostage and Bella running away to spend time with Jacob
    10. Edward following Bella when she heads to Angela's
    11. Jasper preparing the wolf pack and the Cullens for the fight with the newborns
    12. The Tent scene
    13. Jacob finding out about the proposal and getting Bella to kiss him
    14. Bella hating herself and wanting Edward to punish her for being a horrible person
    15. The fight (In the meadow & the fight with Victoria and Riley)
    16. The Voultri and dealing with Bree
    17. Jacob's injuries
    18. Jacob running as a wolf after the wedding invitation

    Okay, so I know have a lot of things I want to see in the movie, but they're key points in the books that shouldn't be missed. I think they've missed a lot of key points from the books that made the books. Eclipse is my second favorite book out of the Saga; (Breaking Dawn, Eclipse, Twilight, and then New Moon). I found New Moon to be my least favorite because I could connect with how Bella was feeling when I was reading it and seemed very depressing (even though it was pivotal in Bella and Jacob's relationship.

    Overall though, I think the movie should be really good and I can't wait to go see it at the midnight showing.

  • team_jacob_baby

    This is the first movie where i have read the book first before the movie so now i have expectations of how it is gonna be and this makes me really nervous. Especially with how great and true to the book new moon was, i hope that David Slade was able to execute the love triangle perfectly because he doesnt seem like a director who working with romance that much but i think he will do great with the fight scenes. i just hope he does a great job with the love triangle.

  • Laura

    I agree with eclipse being the best book and it is my favorite so i really hope that they did not leave anything out and played the main points such as the love triangle to be awsome not to mentation the awsome fight … fingers crossedk

  • Frankie Star

    All I know is what I've been told. That's it's so more “guy-tuned” than the others. So whenever a guy sees my New Moon messenger bag I tell them, “Dude, if you saw the other two and didn't like it…trust me, Eclipse will change your mind FOREVER.”

  • TEAM EDWARD

    this film would be good..
    and may be i would see that twice or more.. hha
    because eclipse is the most interesting book…
    and i believe.. many people will see that movie..

  • TEAMROBSESSEDXXX<3

    Edward won't die, they wouldn't completely change the books cause they'd like lose most of their fans!!!!! and anyways Jacob ends up with Renesmee, where would the story go without Edward! :)

  • Team_RobwardX

    I have the highest hoopes for Eclipse; It is by farr the besst book of the lott!!! I hope they don't leave out any of my fave scenes :S
    I Can't wait to see the fight scene between Edward and Victoria and the tent scene……..OH and i wanna see it when bella punches Jacob…….annd the proposal……annnd Jasper and Rosalies back stories….annnnd…..oh I just can't wait for the whole thiing ;)

  • Team_Robsten ♥

    Edward won't die, they wouldn't completely change the books cause they'd like lose most of their fans!!!!! and anyways Jacob ends up with Renesmee, where would the story go without Edward! :)

  • Team_Robsten ♥

    I have the highest hoopes for Eclipse; It is by farr the besst book of the lott!!! I hope they don't leave out any of my fave scenes :S
    I Can't wait to see the fight scene between Edward and Victoria and the tent scene……..OH and i wanna see it when bella punches Jacob…….annd the proposal……annnd Jasper and Rosalies back stories….annnnd…..oh I just can't wait for the whole thiing ;)

Top Twilight Blogs