Quantcast

Discussion Topic: Which new characters MUST make it into Breaking Dawn film?

Here is this week’s discussion topic! If you have an idea for a topic, email it to [email protected]!

This week there was our first big rumor about casting for Breaking Dawn, that Lee Pace might play Garrett. There are a LOT of new characters in Breaking Dawn that we haven’t seen before. I’m sure all of said characters won’t make it into the film version, but I want to know which characters you think SHOULD make it into the film, and any casting ideas you have. Also, since we are on the subject, we can discuss these new characters’ powers because it’s easy to get everyone mixed up if you haven’t read the book in a while.

I think there are certain obvious ones that are pertinent to the story, unless the story is changed (which I don’t think it will be), such as the Denali coven. That should get you started.

So tell me in the comments!

  • Saraa Connolly13

    I absulutley think all the covens should be in the book. To cut some of them out would make it pointless. I am really looking forward to this movie, not only because of all the amazing things that happen in this book, but also Stephine Meyer is going to be on the set almost everyday. So i know for sure that it will be close to the book. Which is the point of these movies, to bring the books to life. Everything has to be perfect. Which means all the covens need to be apart of this movie.

  • Katie Latta

    I think Tanya and her clan.

  • S. Cieutat

    It seems that the characters have already been decided…according to a casting site. They are doing casting calls in Canada, LA, and New Orleans. Many of the new vamps will be in the film, but I was surprised to see that Irena from the Denali Coven isn't listed.

  • Phoenixliv

    I'm excited to meet Elezar and the Romanians. The Volturi has been so great thus far I wanna see more Ancients!!! They better do the Amazonians well too and of course Renesmee.

    I really enjoyed the “knee hitch” scene in Eclipse and I hope the pillow biting scene on Isle Esme will live up to those same high standards. :)

  • roseteamJACOBomgss

    i think all of the book characters must bere there

    kisses (LOVE TWILIGHT SAGA AND 1000 more times jacob)

    rose_jacob==(L)
    loves ya all

  • Lbragrl_73

    Zaffrina Senna and Kachiri and all the other covens

  • Rmw3485

    What the hell type of question is that?! All the characters, duh….you can't cut anyone it'll ruin the whole story

  • Liz

    Benjamin is such a cool character, as well as Zarfinia and Garrett, they should all be in their. As people have said earlier the Romainans would be good two because they give a bigger back story to the Volturi and why they are proceeded that way.

  • Beachstarblue4

    they should definetely try to fit them all in. they are all very essential.

  • mrs. cullen

    character that had a direct connection w/ bella should be given special attention such as the denali coven. the amazon vampire that helped bella w/ her skill and j. jenks.. and of course don't 3d anyone please.. oh i almost forgot.. the hybrid vamps should also be casted >.<

  • cristina

    i think that ever character in the book should make it into the movies. if they weren't all important then stephanie would have never written about them. they dont all have to have major dialogue and scenes or anything, but they should at least be in them. AND since its going to be made into two movies, it shouldn't be too hard to fit them all in somewhere. i think it will be worth it lol but thats just my opinion

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Maria-Macias/100000756622295 Maria Macias

    Well i think they should add Zafrina to the movie to see how Bella controls her powers after being changed into a vampire

  • Jasminemc16

    I think all new comers to the movie should be in breaking dawn

  • Emilyannw218

    renasmee for sure!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! the entire guard, the wives,the Amazon coven,the denali coven,the,egyptian coven the irish coven,the olimpic cullen for sure (the cullens) ,the romanian coven,the american nomads,the european coven also !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Lynne

    I agree all of the characters should be in the movie even if some only have a small part. Breaking Dawn was a long book but very interesting and it was so hard to put it down! Wow 3 movies would be nice. I can handle watching more of Edward:=)

  • Tríona

    ya you actually need all of the characters there because otherwise the storyline won't make as much sense. There have to be enough vampires there, especially those who are talented like Zafrina, Benjamen etc. because the Volturi need one of their reasons to not just kill all the Cullens right there and then to be clear for those who haven't read the books. :) I CAN'T WAIT FOR BREAKING DAWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :D

  • Tríona

    oh and for all the other non-vampires in the books like J. Jenks and the maid, well the maid doesn't really have to be there though I would be sad to see any of the characters be cut out from the film. J. Jenks and Max have to be there, how else would Bella know what kind of stuff J. does? Oh they also need to have the numbers of wolves and vampires there, obviously they can't introduce them all but they have to actually be there. :)

  • secrete-gal

    well ya itx difficult to say who should b there and who shouldnt b cox ol of them are as important to da film as the main characters are as the film would b incomplite without them………….so its obvioux all are important bt i wish victoria to stay for long…….LOLXXXXX…..XD

  • Angiedesimas

    every chapter i breaking dawn is important to this movie/ we excepted in the other 3 that it had to be broken down, but with breaking dawn every chapter backs up the next so if u leave anything out it may not make much since. please give us fan this one book to where we can enjoy it as much as we did reading it. it is the highlight of the series so please please dont take that away!!!!!! and since it is in two movies u wont have to remove anything or take out any people in this book. we are in luv with these books i have read them 5 times each and im sure im not the only one so give us this leave it as is!!!!!!

  • Angiedesimas

    One more thing. Every vampire friend that comes has a gift to help fight the voltori so we as fans know and luv these gifts they have and to c diffrent kinds of vampires that unite together. This is the big ending we all have been waiting for DONT TAKE THAT AWAY FROM US!!!!!!!!!! COUNTING DOWN THE DAYS UNTIL BREAKING DAWN COMES OUT!!!!! PLEASE VALUE OUR OPINIONS WE DO URS!!!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1833189418 Dana McConkey

    I WANT ALL THE WITNESSES! SOD THE MAID AND ALLL THE VOLTURI! WE NEED ALL THE WITNESSES IT WOULDNT BE RIGHT IF ONLY 10 OF EM WHERE THERE OUTTA THE 20 ODD THAT TURN UP!!!!
    Tanya- Cassidy Freeman.
    Carmen- America Ferrera
    Eleazar- Antonio Banderas
    Kate- Kristen Bell
    Irina- Sophie Myles
    Garrett- Justin Hartley
    Charlotte- Laura Vandervoort
    Peter- Jude Law
    Zafrinia- Zoe Saldana
    Charles- Owen Wilson
    Makenna- Billie Piper
    Siobhan- Erica Durance
    Liam- Sam Worthington
    Maggie- Racheal Hurdwood
    Randell- Logan Huffman
    Mary-Sienna Miller
    Alistar- Mark Hildreth

    AND that is all I cba to do

  • CNC

    Of course they need all of the covens, jjenks, Maxx, and I also think they need to make sure they use Seth more! He was actually a big part in Eclipse and they barely focused on him! I hope they dont cut his parts down too much, Leah too. I also think they need to introduce more of the wolves imprints! Because imprinting is such a big part of the story, and it didnt really come across in the last movie. Claire and Quil especially, to help explain Jake and Ness.

  • melissa

    I want to participate in the new film Breaking Dawn and I read the four books and send an email again that I wanted to do the casting for new characters!!

  • Tk100584

    They should have broken it down into 3 movies just like the book is in 3 parts. Would be easy to include everyone at that point! There is just sooo much information in the book that is necessary! :)

    Everyone is essential …
    The Denalis ESP irina.
    the Amazons Especially Kachuri and Zafrina
    The Irish Coven
    The Egyption Coven
    The Romanians (they are creeptacular!)

    Witnesses on the Volturi side can be minimized though no need for all of those guys!

  • Maria Nieto

    I'm just saying that the movie will be great, huge and fantastic ……. I want to see everyone in the clan, Denali, J. Amazon Jenkens …….. but of course I want to see is the marriage of Bella and Edward Island …… two …… Esme Renesmee's birth ….. … In short, everything …… just looking forward to the premiere.

  • Saraa Connolly13

    I absulutley think all the covens should be in the book. To cut some of them out would make it pointless. I am really looking forward to this movie, not only because of all the amazing things that happen in this book, but also Stephine Meyer is going to be on the set almost everyday. So i know for sure that it will be close to the book. Which is the point of these movies, to bring the books to life. Everything has to be perfect. Which means all the covens need to be apart of this movie.

  • Katie Latta

    I think Tanya and her clan.

  • S. Cieutat

    It seems that the characters have already been decided…according to a casting site. They are doing casting calls in Canada, LA, and New Orleans. Many of the new vamps will be in the film, but I was surprised to see that Irena from the Denali Coven isn't listed.

  • Phoenixliv

    I'm excited to meet Elezar and the Romanians. The Volturi has been so great thus far I wanna see more Ancients!!! They better do the Amazonians well too and of course Renesmee.

    I really enjoyed the “knee hitch” scene in Eclipse and I hope the pillow biting scene on Isle Esme will live up to those same high standards. :)

  • roseteamJACOBomgss

    i think all of the book characters must bere there

    kisses (LOVE TWILIGHT SAGA AND 1000 more times jacob)

    rose_jacob==(L)
    loves ya all

  • Lbragrl_73

    Zaffrina Senna and Kachiri and all the other covens

  • Rmw3485

    What the hell type of question is that?! All the characters, duh….you can't cut anyone it'll ruin the whole story

  • Liz

    Benjamin is such a cool character, as well as Zarfinia and Garrett, they should all be in their. As people have said earlier the Romainans would be good two because they give a bigger back story to the Volturi and why they are proceeded that way.

  • Beachstarblue4

    they should definetely try to fit them all in. they are all very essential.

  • mrs. cullen

    character that had a direct connection w/ bella should be given special attention such as the denali coven. the amazon vampire that helped bella w/ her skill and j. jenks.. and of course don't 3d anyone please.. oh i almost forgot.. the hybrid vamps should also be casted >.<

  • cristina

    i think that ever character in the book should make it into the movies. if they weren't all important then stephanie would have never written about them. they dont all have to have major dialogue and scenes or anything, but they should at least be in them. AND since its going to be made into two movies, it shouldn't be too hard to fit them all in somewhere. i think it will be worth it lol but thats just my opinion

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Maria-Macias/100000756622295 Maria Macias

    Well i think they should add Zafrina to the movie to see how Bella controls her powers after being changed into a vampire

  • bella1981

    the only problem i have with all these characters is how they arrive in the story, it could get repetitive IMO, i always look at stuff like this with an eye to how it's going to be picked apart by critics, and i always go with less is more, not less characters but less times they have to be introduced…
    I also kinda like Jared Padalecki for Garret (he was who i pictured in my head when reading the book) BUT it won't happen, due to his Supernatural schedule… *beefcake* lol

  • Sendos

    i think it is important to keep the 3 major characters edward bella and jacob or else i think the movie would not be as perfect as possible and they are kind of sticked to our imagination imean when reading the story i imagine the events with the actors i watched .

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Madison-Shuman/100000089495447 Madison Shuman

    what makes me mad is Tanya's Family has not been introduced into the movies yet. i have read the whole series and they are apart of eclipse and breaking dawn. they are another “vegetarian” vampire clan and in eclipse the cullens ask for help with the newborns coming Tanya says no we cannot help u because the werewolves killed laurant irena's mate and the cullens would not allow irena 2 get her revenge on the werewolves. in breaking dawn they shop up 2 Bella and Edwards Wedding also they witness that Renesmee is half human half vampire not just vampire. So I think that Tanya's family should be included

  • MeganCullen

    definetly the Denali clan and Garrett. I really like him and the amazons.

  • rob_taylor

    Every character has to be there, but the ones I`d be really dissapointed if they are not there would be the Denali clan, especially Tania, when Bella first meet her, all the vamps, but I would love to see Bella with humans when vamp, like J Jenks and Max and at Isle Esme Gustavo & Kaure. Well, guees those are all the new ones.

  • B

    all of the characters. they have to show bella making arrangements for nessie and jake, they have to show the other half vamp and really they need all the others, maybe not to the point that they get there own story but at least in the background, appearing as the character appeared in the book. CERTAINLY keep the main newbies, those are for sure important to the story.

  • Foreverpink2628

    ya defenitely. all the characters should make the movie. it would be cool if they had an all celebrity vampire cast

  • Debann04

    I've heard a rumor that they aren't going to have Bella's baby in the breaking dawn movies, please tell me it isn't true!

  • veron91

    I just love Breaking Dawn, and I hope they get the Esme isle scenes right..Like when they go to take a swime when they arrive at the island. And the biting the pillow- scenes, and when Edward breaks the bedboard.

  • Dreamer__666

    they need the denali clan….i saw an interview anna kendrick did saying they dont think the humans are going to be back for breaking dawn….jessica, mike and angela need to be at the wedding!

  • Jorosep

    http://aryandjorose.podbean.com/mf/web/xnvyh4/e… we talked about it in this podcast. :)

  • PrisM233

    I've spent a couple of days stewing about this. First off, just because they are making it two movies doesn't mean they'll have the screen time for all these new characters because most of them won't come in till the second part. The assumption is that Part 1 ends with Bella's change, so the only new characters in the first part would be the Denalis at the wedding, and the maid at the island (because she's the one who tells Edward the baby n Bella will die and he decides that they'll take it out of her before it does any damage). Gustavo is extraneous, and not necessary.

    Now, for BD Part 2, the characters that MUST be in are all the wolves (because their numbers stop the Volturi advance, but they don't need to cast their human forms since they don't show till the battle), the entire guard (because their numbers are what makes this battle such a lost cause and shows how big a deal all of them coming for punishment is), Nahuel (because he is the solution, Huilen isn't really necessary as Nahuel could just tell them he is venomous and proof isn't really required), and some of the additional covens (all the Denali's remain).

    Now the thing about all the characters being necessary for their different parts isn't necessarily true, because they could just lump two characters into one, which is most likely what they'll do. Of course the “talented” vamps (Zafrina, Kate, Benjamin and Maggie) will be required, but even then, other than the Amazons since that's where Nahuel comes from, they could combine coven members and exclude the unecessary ones. IMO

  • Mypartysuxx

    tanya i am sooo mad that they didnt talk about tanya in eclipse and it makes me wonder if they will have her in breaking dawn

Top Twilight Blogs